PORTSMOUTH - Nadine Thompson said she did not get a jury of her peers when an all-white jury on Friday ruled that Southwest Airlines did not discriminate against her for being black. But Lance Hellman of Portsmouth, a juror in the case, said race had nothing whatever to do with the verdict.
Thompson, a cosmetics executive from Exeter, said Monday she would not appeal the verdict because she said has no desire to again be characterized in public "as a fat, black, foul-mouthed ghetto momma. It was the most humiliating thing I’ve ever gone through in my life."
A U.S. District Court jury of eight people deliberated for just over an hour Friday before finding against Thompson.
In 2003, Thompson, who is significantly overweight, boarded a Southwest Airlines flight in Manchester. She was asked to leave her seat, under the airline’s "customer of size" policy, and talk to airline officials in the airport lobby about buying two tickets to accommodate her size. There, according to testimony, she became verbally abusive and was escorted out of the airport by sheriff’s deputies.
During testimony, Southwest Airlines employees said they did make a mistake in the way they asked her to leave the plane, but they never used racist words and were concerned solely with her weight.
Nadine Thompson Exeter resident who sued airline |
Hellman said he knew nothing about the case when he was first seated on the jury, and on first seeing her "I had a great deal of sympathy for her. Here was this overweight black woman being picked on by the big airline. It was kind of a David vs. Goliath thing, I thought. And I’ve always been partial to David."
He said it was true that of the 100 potential jurors called to the district courthouse that day, he did not see people of color "but that’s a fair sampling of New Hampshirites."
Over the course of the four-day trial, he said it "became apparent to me that she didn’t have a case. She was trying to make an issue of race and it was really her weight," he said. When the jurors were finally able to deliberate, Hellman said, it became quickly apparent that everyone felt the same way he did.
He said he was particularly swayed by the testimony of the employee who asked her to leave the plane and whom she subsequently called "a racist motherf*****."
"I could sympathize with her anger. But she lost it," he said.
When Thompson said afterward that there was "no one to advocate for race," he felt it implied he was racist. "Nothing could be further from the truth."
Lance Hallman Juror from Portsmouth |
But Thompson said that wasn’t at all what she meant.
"I honor and respect that he did the best he could. I respect that all of the jurors did the best they could," she said.
"But it was not a jury of my peers. There wasn’t even an ethnic minority there to advocate for me."
Hellman, who said he would be glad to meet Thompson and talk with her, said he felt in the final analysis that she should consider looking within herself.
"I am sympathetic for the underdog. And I can understand her not wanting to feel undervalued. But I think she has some growing to do."CORPUS CHRISTI, Texas - A 78-year-old hunting companion of Vice President Dick Cheney was recovering in stable condition Monday after Cheney accidentally shot him during a weekend quail hunting trip, a hospital official said.
Harry Whittington "rested well last night," said Peter Banko, hospital administrator at Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial. The hospital listed Whittington's condition as "very stable," he said.
Whittington, an Austin attorney, was flown to the hospital after Cheney accidentally shot him late Saturday afternoon at the Armstrong Ranch, hitting him with birdshot.
"It's not critical. It's not serious. It's just stable at this time," Banko said at a morning briefing. He said admitting Whittington to the trauma-intensive care unit was "a fairly common procedure" for a patient hit by a spray of the small pellets.
"I don't know how much spray he has got," Banko said. "My understanding from the physicians is that after you get peppered, sometimes they need to do exploratory surgeries if it gets lodged in a little deeper. Sometimes, it's tweezers. I can't really comment on how extensively he was sprayed."
Banko said he did not know when Whittington would be released, but in the meantime he was being visited by family and friends.
The vice president visited Whittington and his wife before returning to Washington on Sunday. Cheney "was pleased to see that he's doing fine and in good spirits," said Cheney spokeswoman Lea Anne McBride.
Whittington sent word through a hospital official that he would not comment on the incident out of respect for Cheney.
Ranch owner Katharine Armstrong told The Associated Press that the accident occurred after Cheney, Whittington and another hunter got out of a car to shoot at a covey of quail.
She said Whittington went to retrieve a bird he shot. Cheney and the third hunter, whom she would not identify, walked to another spot and discovered a second covey of quail.
Whittington "came up from behind the vice president and the other hunter and didn't signal them or indicate to them or announce himself," said Armstrong, who was in the car.
"The vice president didn't see him," she said. "The covey flushed and the vice president picked out a bird and was following it and shot. And by god, Harry was in the line of fire and got peppered pretty good."
Armstrong said the shotgun pellets broke the skin.
"It knocked him silly. But he was fine. He was talking. His eyes were open. It didn't get in his eyes or anything like that," she said.
Each of the hunters was wearing a bright orange vest at the time, Armstrong said.
The accident was not reported publicly by the vice president's office for nearly 24 hours, and then only after it was reported by the Corpus Christi Caller-Times on its Web site Sunday.
McBride said the vice president's office did not tell reporters about the accident Saturday because they were deferring to Armstrong to handle the announcement of what happened on her property.
Armstrong said everyone at the ranch was so "focused" on Whittington's health Saturday that it wasn't until Sunday she called the Caller-Times to report the accident. Her ranch is about 60 miles southwest of Corpus Christi.
Sally Whittington told The Dallas Morning News her father was being observed because of swelling from some of the welts on his neck. His face "looks like chicken pox, kind of," she said.
Whittington has been a private practice attorney in Austin since 1950 and has long been active in Texas Republican politics. He's been appointed to several state boards, including when then-Gov. George W. Bush named him to the Texas Funeral Service Commission.
Armstrong said Cheney is a longtime friend who comes to the ranch to hunt about once a year and is "a very safe sportsman." She said Whittington is a regular, too, but she thought it was the first time the two men hunted together.
The 50,000-acre Armstrong ranch has been in the influential South Texas family since the turn of the last century. Katharine is the daughter of Tobin Armstrong, a politically connected rancher who has been a guest at the White House and spent 48 years as director of the Texas and Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association. He died in October. Cheney was among the dignitaries who attended his funeral.
Cheney was legally hunting with a license he purchased in November, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department spokesman Steve Lightfoot said.
Associated Press writers Nedra Pickler in Washington and Paul J. Weber in Dallas contributed to this report.
__________________________DATE - 02/12/06 Trenton ( 3) AT Gwinnett ( 4)
SCORE BY PERIODS
Trenton 1 2 0--3
Gwinnett 0 1 3--4
I was going to post the rest of the box score here, but it screwed up the formatting, so I
had to say forget it.
Then it was home, urchin 1.0 to bed (followed by ninja visits at 11:34pm,
which was 31 minutes after I fell asleep) and again at around 12:30 or for
"bad dweams" and a full pullup.
Well, that about covers my weekend. Since it's my 300th post, I figured
I should writesome sort of haiku:
300 entries.
Talk about wasting some time.
That's a lot of words.
Happy race season everybody!! In just two days and a wakeup, we'll
be watching racing full on. Here's the schedule for the week:
Thursday: Nextel Cup Twin 150 mile qualifying races
Friday: Craftsman truck race at night
Saturday: Busch Series race
Sunday: Daytona 500
(Insert Dukes of Hazzard rebel yell here).